Leaking Water Heater: What to Turn Off, and in What Order
It can be, because a leaking tank is hot water under pressure with electricity or gas attached, so deal with the energy before the water. On an electric heater, turn off the power at the breaker; on a gas heater, a steady leak is on National Grid's own list of gas emergencies, so report it to the gas utility as one. Then stop the tank refilling at the cold water valve on its inlet, or at the main shutoff if that valve will not close.
Already know you need someone out? Call (315) 640-3590.
A leaking water heater, in order
Energy off
Breaker, or the gas utilityAn electric tank at the breaker. A steady leak from a gas heater is a gas emergency by National Grid's own list.
Stop the tank refilling
Cold water inlet valveThe county's permit checklist calls for a full bore valve on the incoming cold line. If it will not close, use the main shutoff.
Leave the relief valve pipe alone
Never plug itState code allows no valve and no threaded end on that pipe, so it can always discharge.
Photograph the tank and the floor
Before it is hauled awayThe insurer can refuse to pay for damage repaired before it has inspected.
Replacement decided in daylight
Permit firstIn Onondaga County a new heater goes in under a plumbing permit, taken out first.
US CPSC; CDC; National Grid gas emergency guidance; Residential Code of New York State P2804; Onondaga County Plumbing Control.
Where the water is coming from tells you how urgent it is
Look before you touch anything, because the source changes what comes next. Every storage heater in New York carries a relief valve near the top of the tank. Section P2804 of the state's Residential Code requires it to open at no more than 150 psi of pressure or 210 degrees Fahrenheit, and section P2804.6.1 requires its discharge pipe to end in the same room, pointing at the floor, a pan or a drain, no more than 6 inches above the floor, where the people in the house can see it. Water coming out of the end of that pipe means the valve opened because something was too hot or the pressure too high, which is a reason to shut off the energy first. The same code allows no valve and no threaded connection at the end of that pipe, so never plug or cap it to stop the drip: it exists to let the tank relieve itself. Water pooling from the body or the base of the tank is the tank. Water dripping from a joint on the pipes above it may be a connection rather than the heater.
Electric heater: turn the power off at the breaker
An electric tank has heating elements wired to the service panel, and water is now somewhere near them. The CDC's advice where electrical equipment has gotten wet or is in or near water is to turn off the power at the main breaker or fuse on the service panel. If only the heater is affected, the breaker labeled for it may be enough; if the water has spread to other equipment or outlets, use the main. The Consumer Product Safety Commission says to shut off the current at the breaker or fuse before removing an electric heater's access panels, which is a reminder that nothing on the tank itself should be opened with the power on. Turning the power off also stops the elements heating an emptying tank. Once the breaker is off, the tank can wait for the plumber.
Gas heater: a steady leak is on National Grid's gas emergency list
National Grid publishes what it treats as a gas emergency for Upstate New York customers, and a continuous flow of water leaking from a gas water heater is on that list, beside an abnormally high or low flame, gas to an appliance that cannot be shut off, roaring, hissing or whistling from gas pipes, and symptoms of carbon monoxide exposure such as headache, nausea, lethargy and disorientation. So a gas heater that is pouring water is a gas utility question before it is a plumbing one: report it to your gas utility as an emergency and follow what they say. That matters in this metro because so many homes are on gas. In the Town of DeWitt, for example, 79.3 percent of households heat with utility gas. While the leak is dealt with, it is worth knowing one related warning from the Consumer Product Safety Commission: gas appliances, including older water heaters, can ignite flammable vapors, so gasoline and gasoline powered equipment should never be stored where that could happen.
Stop the tank refilling from the cold side
A leaking tank keeps leaking for as long as the supply keeps filling it, so once the energy is dealt with, close the water to it. On a heater installed under an Onondaga County permit there should be a full bore shutoff on the cold line feeding it, because the county's residential water heater permit checklist asks for one; it is on the cold pipe running into the tank, usually at the top. Close it fully. If there is no valve, or it will not move, close the main shutoff where the water service comes into the house, as described in the guide to what to do first after a pipe bursts. Do not open the drain valve at the bottom to empty the tank yourself tonight. The Consumer Product Safety Commission says most adults suffer third degree burns from 150 degree water in two seconds and from 140 degree water in six, and a tank that has been heating is full of it. Leave draining to the plumber.
The tank itself is rarely what a policy pays for
If the water has damaged floors, walls or belongings, the insurance question is the same one as for a burst pipe, with one difference worth knowing before anyone hauls the old heater away. The standard ISO homeowners form covers loss caused by an accidental discharge of water from a household appliance, but states that it does not cover loss to the appliance the water escaped from, and it excludes wear and tear, deterioration and corrosion while restoring coverage for the resulting water damage. So the heater is usually yours to replace, and the damage it caused is the part a claim concerns. Photograph the tank, where it leaked, the floor and anything wet before any of it is moved, and do not let the old tank leave the house until your insurer has said whether it wants to see it: New York's Department of Financial Services says an insurer can refuse to pay for damage repaired before it has inspected. The guide to burst pipe insurance claims in New York goes through the rest.
No hot water and no leak can usually wait until morning
This is the reassuring case. A heater that has stopped making hot water, with no water on the floor and nothing on National Grid's list, is an inconvenience rather than an emergency, and it can be booked in ordinary hours like any other repair. If you rent, it may not be yours to fix at all. In the City of Syracuse, where 58.4 percent of occupied homes are rented according to Census estimates, section 27-11 of the Property Conservation Code requires the owner to furnish adequate hot water and keep the plumbing the owner supplies in good working order, and section 27-52 requires hot water at no less than 110 degrees Fahrenheit at every required fixture. The state's Property Maintenance Code sets the same 110 degree floor in section 505.4. Tell the landlord in writing and keep a copy. If nothing happens, the city office that enforces that code is the Division of Code Enforcement, on 315-448-8695, Monday to Friday during office hours.
Replacing the heater is a daylight decision
A heater that has failed at midnight does not need to be replaced at midnight, and in this county it should not be. In Onondaga County a new water heater is permitted work, with the permit taken out before the heater goes in, and the county explains why: a heater connected, vented or spaced wrongly can cause an electric shock or a fire. That is a decision to make with the energy off, the water off and a written quote in front of you, not with a tank dripping behind you. Tonight's part is making the heater safe, and a licensed plumber can do that and quote the rest afterwards. Tell us whether the heater is gas or electric, where the water is coming from and whether the power, gas and cold water are off, and we will connect you to a licensed, insured plumber who takes work in your town.
Sources used in this guide


Section P2804 of the Residential Code of New York State requires a water heater to have a pressure relief and a temperature relief valve or a combination valve. Pressure relief must open at not less than 25 psi above system pressure and not more than 150 psi; temperature relief must sense the top 6 inches of the tank and open at not more than 210 degrees Fahrenheit. No check or shutoff valve may be installed between the relief valve and the tank or between the valve and the end of its discharge pipe.
Source: UpCodes, reproducing the 2020 Residential Code of New York State, accessed 2026-09-24
Section P2804.6.1 of the Residential Code of New York State requires the relief valve discharge pipe to discharge through an air gap in the same room as the water heater, to the floor, a pan, a waste receptor or outdoors, to a point readily observable by the occupants, in a manner that does not cause personal injury, terminating not more than 6 inches above the floor, with no valves, no tee fittings, no trap and no threaded connection at the end.
Source: UpCodes, reproducing the 2020 Residential Code of New York State, accessed 2026-09-24
The CDC advises that if electrical circuits and electrical equipment have gotten wet or are in or near water, the power should be turned off at the main breaker or fuse on the service panel.
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, accessed 2026-09-24
The US Consumer Product Safety Commission urges users to set water heaters to 120 degrees Fahrenheit. It states that most adults suffer third degree burns from 150 degree water in two seconds, from 140 degree water in six seconds and from 130 degree water in thirty seconds, and that even at 120 degrees a five minute exposure could cause third degree burns. For electric water heaters it says to shut off current at the circuit breaker or fuse before removing access panels to adjust the thermostats.
Source: US Consumer Product Safety Commission, accessed 2026-09-24
National Grid's list of what it considers a gas emergency includes a continuous flow of water leaking from a gas heating unit or water heater, along with an abnormally high or low flame or no gas at all gas appliances, gas to an appliance that cannot be shut off, roaring, hissing or whistling from gas pipes, and symptoms of carbon monoxide exposure such as headache, nausea, lethargy and disorientation.
Source: National Grid, accessed 2026-09-24
ACS 2020 to 2024 estimates give the Town of DeWitt a median year built of 1963 across 10,996 housing units, with 79.3 percent of occupied units heating with utility gas, among the highest in this metro, 26.4 percent renter occupied, and 6.5 percent of units vacant.
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 five year estimates, accessed 2026-09-24
The CPSC Flammable Liquids safety alert says never to store flammable liquids or gasoline powered equipment inside a home, utility room or garage where vapors could be ignited by a spark or flame, and states that while newer residential water heaters are designed to prevent flashback fires, gas fired appliances such as clothes dryers, furnaces and older water heaters can ignite flammable vapors.
Source: US Consumer Product Safety Commission, accessed 2026-09-24
The Onondaga County Residential Water Heater Permit Checklist dated June 10, 2026 must be submitted with the permit application and generally requires a picture of each item, including one showing a placard with the date, plumber's name, homeowner and job address. Items include a full port valve on the cold water inlet, a temperature and pressure relief valve with its discharge tube piped to within 6 inches of the floor with no threaded end, a drain valve, a properly fitted flue, the temperature set to 120 degrees Fahrenheit, and a thermal expansion tank where a pressure reducing valve or reduced pressure zone device is present. An onsite inspection can be requested where pictures are not possible.
Source: Onondaga County Department of Water Environment Protection, accessed 2026-09-24
Under the ISO HO 00 03 form, loss caused by an accidental discharge or overflow of water from within a plumbing, heating or air conditioning system or a household appliance is covered, including the cost to tear out and replace part of the building when that is necessary to repair the system or appliance. The form states that it does not cover loss to the system or appliance from which the water escaped.
Source: Insurance Services Office, via Maine Bureau of Insurance, accessed 2026-09-24
The ISO HO 00 03 form excludes loss caused by wear and tear, marring or deterioration; mechanical breakdown, latent defect or inherent vice; and smog, rust or other corrosion, or dry rot. An exception restores coverage for resulting water damage from an accidental discharge from a plumbing system or household appliance, but not for the worn or corroded part itself.
Source: Insurance Services Office, via Maine Bureau of Insurance, accessed 2026-09-24
The NY DFS guide says it is important to protect property against further damage, that the cost of that protection is generally covered and reimbursed, and to save all receipts for temporary fixes. It states that no permanent repairs should be made until the company or its representative has inspected the property, that the company has the right to inspect the property in its damaged condition, and that it can refuse to pay for damage that is repaired before inspection.
Source: New York State Department of Financial Services, accessed 2026-09-24
American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 estimates put 34,927 of the City of Syracuse's 59,816 occupied housing units, 58.4 percent, as renter occupied, the highest share of the sixteen towns in this metro. Of 67,601 units, 7,785, or 11.5 percent, were vacant, and 4,262 of those were classed as other vacant rather than for rent, for sale or seasonal.
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 five year estimates, accessed 2026-09-24
Section 27-11 of the Syracuse Property Conservation Code requires the owner to maintain all electrical, plumbing and other facilities supplied by the owner in good working order and to furnish adequate heat and hot water, except in units with individual heating or hot water systems, which must still be capable of providing adequate heat and hot water. Section 27-52 requires water heating facilities capable of delivering at least 2.5 gallons per minute at not less than 110 degrees Fahrenheit at every required fixture.
Source: City of Syracuse, accessed 2026-09-24
Section 505.4 of the 2020 Property Maintenance Code of New York State requires water heating facilities to be properly installed, maintained and capable of supplying water at every required sink, lavatory, bathtub, shower and laundry facility at not less than 110 degrees Fahrenheit, and requires an approved combination temperature and pressure relief valve and discharge pipe to be properly installed and maintained. Section 506.2 requires every plumbing stack, vent, waste and sewer line to be kept free from obstructions, leaks and defects.
Source: UpCodes, reproducing the 2020 Property Maintenance Code of New York State, accessed 2026-09-24
The City of Syracuse Division of Code Enforcement lists its contact as 315-448-8695 and [email protected], with office hours Monday to Friday 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Source: City of Syracuse Division of Code Enforcement, accessed 2026-09-24
Onondaga County Plumbing Control requires a plumbing permit before a new water heater is installed, explaining that this household essential can be dangerous if installed incorrectly and that improper installation through incorrect connections, venting or clearance could result in electrical shock or fire.
Source: Onondaga County Department of Water Environment Protection, accessed 2026-09-24
Services this guide relates to
Need someone to look at it?
Send the details and we will come back to you.
